• 0 Posts
  • 351 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 3rd, 2024

help-circle

  • People are losing confidence in the systems of law, order, and justice. The social contract is being broken by the ruling elite. When people lose confidence in these things and see no avenue for justice, they turn to extreme measures.

    Killing someone is always a terrible and avoidable outcome, but there are cases where we consider it just: defense of yourself or others, to prevent greater harm, etc.

    People are seeing great injustices and great dangers and they have no confidence in the systems that are supposed to address those things. Naturally, they’re behaving accordingly.

    The social contract requires good faith and consent and can’t just be taken for granted.







  • I’m referring to people talking about the trolley problem, defense, war, etc.

    When it comes to killing the CEO I’m not gonna argue it because your position is valid.

    I agree it’s “wrong” but I won’t hide my smile, I wouldn’t be sad about some other similar incidents either.

    When there is no justice, there can be no peace.


  • Yes but now you’re discussing nuance whereas in your replies to everyone else you’re making a blanket statement that murder is always wrong.

    You can’t reject other peoples’ nuanced arguments with a blanket statement then retreat to making your own when confronted.

    Your POV is valid, and I’m not telling you you’re wrong to believe it, but you haven’t been engaging with others in good faith.





  • the world isn’t so black and white, and this kind of attitude (preservation of the status quo, valuing order over justice) is what allows evil to persist.

    Sometimes we need to get our hands dirty, and you’re benefiting today from the people willing to do that in past generations.

    Sometimes it’s armies storming a beach, sometimes it’s the people checking those in power